Contact our Georgia national whistleblower lawyers today. Call us at 770-643-1606

How Does the Federal False Claims Act Affect Medicare False Claims Cases?

federal false claims act medicare

federal false claims act medicareThere are many ways in which the Federal False Claims Act affects Medicare false claims cases. To understand how this happens, you need to learn what the False Claims Act is, what it covers, and how its enforcement works.

The False Claims Act, like many other piece of legislation, is complex. Interpretation is best left up to the professionals, but those who are looking to hire an attorney should familiarize themselves with the legislation and enforcement so they know what to expect.

What Is the Federal False Claims Act?

The Federal False Claims Act is a piece of legislation that assigns liability to individuals and organizations that defraud programs of the government. This Act is what the government usually uses as a legal basis when suing individuals or organizations for fraud.

It is important to note that the act contains a provision (called a qui tam provision) that allows other people to file actions on behalf of the government. Legislation calls these people “relators” but most of us know them as “whistleblowers.” This provision is very useful, as whistleblowers file a significant portion of suits brought under this Act. In fact, whistleblowers brought 70% of lawsuits. These suits recovered $27.2 billion in the period between 1987 and 2013. Many of these lawsuits related to false Medicare claims.

History of Qui Tam Laws

To understand the False Claims Act and its qui tam provision, you need to look at the history of similar legislation. This history influenced the False Claims Act during its writing and continues to influence enforcement of the Act today.
Qui tam laws date back to the Middle Ages. Specifically, they got their start in England. King Edward II offered one-third of the money recovered from corrupt government officials to those who reported them. This legal practice continued under Henry VIII, who ruled that whistleblowers, or “common informers,” could sue landowners in court for cases related to the titles of different pieces of land. A version of this law is still in force in Ireland, although England has since repealed the law.

The idea of a whistleblower bringing a lawsuit for the public good first appeared in America in the Commonwealth of Massachusetts. The penalties for fraudulent bread sales went to two parties: the person who reported the offense and the town in which the crime occurred. Other states like New York, Connecticut, Virginia, and South Carolina followed Massachusetts’ example.

The Civil War brought about the start of the False Claims Act in the United States. Due to the amounts of money spent by both the Confederate and Union governments, many people involved in the government saw an opportunity to commit fraudulent acts and enrich themselves. Congress passed the False Claims Act on March 2, 1863. As Abraham Lincoln was president at the time, some called it the “Lincoln Law.”

It is important to note that the False Claims Act contained a qui tam provision from the start. This provision is responsible for most of the lawsuits brought under the act, including most of the biggest Medicare false claims suits.

Qui Tam Laws and Medicare False Claims Suits

Up until the 1990s, most suits filed under the False Claims Act related to military spending. However, Medicare has become the focus of enforcement of the Act. The monetary value of the recoveries associated with Medicare fraud reached 40% of the total in 2008.

One of the most influential Medicare false claims suits was Franklin v. Parke-Davis, filed in 1996. The case concerned bills submitted to the Medicare/Medicaid programs by health care providers. They claimed they had provided certain treatment, when in fact, they had not.

It is interesting to note that many Medicare false claims suits filed under the False Claims Act concern the marketing of pharmaceutical companies for off-label (non-FDA-approved) usages of drugs. When Medicare pays for these prescriptions used in non-FDA-approved cases, it constitutes fraud.

Liability for Medicare Fraud under the False Claims Act

The False Claims Act establishes specific circumstances under which a person or organization can be liable for fraud against the government, including Medicare fraud. The most common circumstance is knowingly presenting a false claim for payment. Those who commit this fraud often also fabricate evidence to support their fraud, which is the second provision that often applies in Medicare fraud cases.

Find out more about how the Federal False Claims Act affects Medicare false claims cases by contacting Bothwell Law Group online. Our legal team at Bothwell Law Group has many years of experience working on Medicare false claims cases that fall under the purview of the Federal False Claims Act. This sort of experience is rare and is exactly what people involved in these cases need to seek out.

How Common Are Whistleblower Medicare Fraud Cases?

Medicare Fraud Cases

Medicare Fraud CasesYou might have heard about a few Medicare fraud cases here and there, but you probably don’t realize how big the problem is. Did you know Medicare and Medicaid fraud costs taxpayers billions of dollars every single year? Or, that an estimated 10% of Medicare and Medicaid claims filed are fraudulent? It’s true. And in the current economic climate, our government hardly has billions to spare.

This is what makes whistleblowing so powerful, and why the government continues to offer rich payouts to individuals who file qui tam lawsuits. As the primary remedy for fraud and false claims, they offer as much as 30% of the amount recovered to the party who filed suit. As you’ll see below, this can end up being quite lucrative under the right circumstance.

History: Medicare Fraud Cases in 2013

At the time, 2013 was a banner year for fraud recoveries. Efforts netted over $3 billion for the federal government, of which over 85% was related to health care fraud. These cases netted significant dollars for the state as well: $443 million went directly back to Medicaid as a result of these recoveries.

Most of the fraud pertained to drugs and medical devices covered under federally insured health programs specifically focused on the improper promotion of drugs for uses not tested and approved by the FDA. Abbot Laboratories, Inc. paid $1.5 billion to resolve allegations against a dementia drug, with $800 million being comprised of federal and state civil recoveries.

History: Medicare Fraud Cases in 2014

In 2014, over seven hundred whistleblower lawsuits were filed on behalf of the government. This was also the first year in which recoveries exceeded $5 billion (it was $5.69 billion, to be exact). Of this amount, $2.3 billion was related to federal health programs like Medicare and Medicaid; the fifth straight year the department netted more than $2 billion in this arena.

Johnson & Johnson, along with its subsidiaries, paid $1.1 billion to settle claims of off-label prescription marketing. Omnicare came in a distant second, paying $116 million to resolve allegations of an illegal kickback scheme.

History: Medicare Fraud Cases in 2015

While much less than 2014, the Justice Department still clocked a cool $3.5 billion as a result of judgments in civil cases pertaining to false claims. This was also the fourth year in a row that Justice beat the $3 billion mark. Since the tightening of legislation back in 2009, a grand total of $26.4 billion has been recovered under the False Claims Act.

Nearly two-thirds of the recovered monies in 2015 were a result of claims related to federal health care fraud. There were a few large settlements, but nothing as large as previous years:

  • DaVita paid $450 million to settle claims it generated unnecessary waste and billed the government for costs that could have been avoided.
  • DaVita also spent $350 million to settle claims it paid kickbacks to physicians in exchange for positive clinic referrals.
  • 500 different hospitals settled for $330 million after allegedly implanting cardiac devices in Medicare patients, contrary to the established rules and regulations.

Wondering If You’ve Got a Medicare Fraud Case?

Still have questions about Medicare fraud cases? Call 770.643.1606  to contact the Bothwell Law Group online.