Scroll Top
Bothwell Law Group 304 Macy Dr, Roswell, GA 30076

Comprehensive Guide on What Is Qui Tam for Whistleblowers

Qui tam is a legal concept which allows private individuals, known as whistleblowers, to file lawsuits on behalf of the government against entities committing fraud against federal programs. Qui tam lawsuits are a crucial tool in uncovering and combating fraud, helping to recover billions of dollars for the government each year.

This comprehensive guide will explore the definition and process of qui tam lawsuits, who can become a whistleblower, the protections and rewards available, and notable examples of successful qui tam cases. Understanding these aspects can empower potential whistleblowers to come forward and contribute to the fight against fraud.

Understanding Qui Tam

Qui tam, pronounced “kee tam” or “kwee tam,” originates from the Latin phrase “qui tam pro domino rege quam pro se ipso in hac parte sequitur,” meaning “he who sues in this matter for the king as well as for himself.” The term refers to a provision under the False Claims Act (FCA) that allows private citizens to file lawsuits on behalf of the federal government against entities committing fraud against government programs.

A qui tam lawsuit is a legal action where a whistleblower, known as a qui tam relator, reports fraud involving government funds. This could include submitting false claims, overbilling for services, or delivering substandard products. The FCA empowers whistleblowers to file these lawsuits and provides them with legal protection. Once a qui tam case is filed, it remains sealed while the Department of Justice (DOJ) investigates the allegations.

A qui tam relator is a private citizen who initiates a qui tam action. They could be employees, contractors, or other individuals with insider knowledge of the fraud. The relator plays a crucial role in exposing fraudulent activities and is eligible to receive a significant percentage of the recovered funds if the case is successful. This incentivizes individuals to come forward and report fraud, thereby protecting taxpayer dollars and ensuring the integrity of government programs.

Statistics show that qui tam lawsuits have been highly effective in recovering funds for the federal government, particularly in federal health care programs. According to the DOJ, from 1987 to 2020, over $62 billion has been recovered through qui tam cases. These lawsuits are vital in the health care industry, where fraudulent claims for durable medical equipment and unnecessary medical services are common.

Who Can Become a Whistleblower?

Under the FCA, any private citizen with knowledge of fraud against the federal government can become a whistleblower, also known as a qui tam relator. This includes employees, contractors, or other individuals with insider information about false claims submitted for government funds. Law enforcement officers, current or former employees of the offending company, and even competitors can be eligible, provided they have non-public, firsthand information about the fraudulent activities.

Steps to File a Qui Tam Lawsuit

  1. Consultation with a Qui Tam Attorney: The first step is to consult with qui tam whistleblower lawyers who specialize in FCA cases to assess the validity of the claim and gather necessary documentation.
  2. Filing the Complaint: The whistleblower, with the help of their attorney, files a qui tam lawsuit under seal in a federal district court. The complaint remains confidential to allow the Department of Justice (DOJ) to investigate.
  3. Government Investigation: The DOJ, along with other federal agencies, investigates the allegations. This period can take several months or even years.
  4. Decision to Intervene: After the investigation, the DOJ decides whether to intervene and take over the case or allow the whistleblower to proceed independently.
  5. Case Unsealed: If the DOJ intervenes or the whistleblower proceeds independently, the case is unsealed, and the defendant is served with the complaint.

By following these steps and adhering to the legal requirements, whistleblowers can help combat fraud against government programs and potentially receive a significant percentage of the recovered funds.

Safely Reporting Fraud

To safely report fraud involving government funds, whistleblowers should first consult with qui tam attorneys who specialize in False Claims Act cases. This ensures that their identity and case details remain confidential. The attorney will assist in filing a qui tam lawsuit under seal in federal court, which keeps the information private during the Department of Justice (DOJ) investigation. Directly reporting fraud to the DOJ or other federal agencies is also an option, but legal guidance helps protect the whistleblower’s rights and strengthens the case.

The False Claims Act provides significant protections for qui tam whistleblowers against retaliation. This includes safeguarding them from being fired, demoted, or harassed due to reporting fraud. If retaliation occurs, whistleblowers can sue for reinstatement, double back pay, and compensation for damages. These protections encourage individuals to come forward without fear of losing their job or facing other negative consequences.

Timeline of Qui Tam Cases

The timeline of a qui tam case under the False Claims Act can vary significantly. On average, qui tam cases take between 3 to 5 years from filing to resolution. This duration includes the initial investigation by the Department of Justice (DOJ), which can take several months to years, depending on the complexity of the allegations and the amount of evidence.

Once the DOJ decides whether to intervene, the case proceeds through the legal system, which can involve settlement negotiations, pre-trial motions, and potentially a trial. Throughout this process, qui tam whistleblowers, with the help of their qui tam attorneys, play a crucial role in providing evidence and supporting the case.

Rewards for Qui Tam Whistleblowers

Qui tam whistleblowers can receive substantial financial rewards for their role in exposing fraud against the federal government. Under the FCA, whistleblowers, or qui tam relators, are eligible to receive between 15% to 30% of the total amount recovered by the government. The exact percentage depends on various factors, including whether the government intervenes in the case and the extent of the whistleblower’s contribution to the case.

To qualify for a reward, the whistleblower must provide original information that significantly contributes to the recovery of funds. The information must be detailed and specific, leading to the successful prosecution or settlement of the qui tam case. Additionally, the relator must adhere to the procedures outlined in the FCA, including filing the lawsuit under seal and providing the DOJ with all pertinent information and evidence.

Protection for Whistleblowers

The Federal False Claims Act includes qui tam provision that provides robust legal protections for whistleblowers. Under the qui tam provisions, whistleblowers are protected from retaliation by their employers. This includes protection against being fired, demoted, harassed, or otherwise discriminated against for reporting fraud involving government funds. If retaliation occurs, whistleblowers can file a lawsuit seeking reinstatement, double back pay, and compensation for any damages, including litigation costs and attorney fees.

Steps to Ensure Personal Safety and Job Security

  1. Consult a Qui Tam Attorney: Before reporting fraud, consult with a qui tam attorney or FCA lawyers to understand your rights and the protections available under the FCA.
  2. Confidential Reporting: File the qui tam lawsuit under seal to keep your identity and the details of the case confidential during the DOJ’s investigation.
  3. Document Everything: Keep detailed records of any retaliatory actions taken by your employer after reporting the fraud. This documentation will be crucial if you need to pursue legal action for retaliation.
  4. Legal Support: Work closely with your attorney throughout the process to ensure all legal protections are enforced and to receive guidance on maintaining your personal safety and job security.

Examples of Qui Tam Cases

  1. GlaxoSmithKline Case: In 2012, GlaxoSmithKline paid $3 billion to settle allegations of improper marketing and pricing of drugs. The whistleblowers in this case received a combined total of $150 million as their share of the recovery.
  2. Pfizer Case: In 2009, Pfizer paid $2.3 billion to resolve allegations of fraud related to the marketing of several drugs. The whistleblowers were awarded $102 million for their role in exposing the fraud. This case underscored the importance of adhering to approved drug uses and significantly impacted corporate practices in the pharmaceutical industry​.
  3. HCA Healthcare Case: In 2003, HCA Healthcare, the largest hospital chain in the U.S., agreed to pay over $631 million to settle allegations of fraud related to billing for unnecessary medical services and inflating hospital costs. Whistleblowers were awarded approximately $151 million for their contributions. This case led to more stringent compliance and auditing procedures within the healthcare industry​.

    Impact of These Cases on Public Policy and Corporate Practices

    Qui tam lawsuits have a profound impact on public policy and corporate practices. They help recover billions of dollars for the federal government and deter future fraud by imposing significant financial penalties on violators. These cases also lead to stricter regulatory oversight and improved compliance programs across various industries, particularly in healthcare and pharmaceuticals. By exposing fraudulent practices, qui tam whistleblowers help ensure that government funds are used appropriately and that public health and safety are protected.

Requirements for a Qui Tam Whistleblower

To qualify as a qui tam whistleblower under the False Claims Act (FCA), an individual must have direct, non-public knowledge of fraudulent activities involving government funds. This can include employees, contractors, or others with insider information. The whistleblower, also known as a qui tam relator, must be able to provide original information that significantly contributes to the case.

The information should not already be part of a public disclosure unless the whistleblower is the original source of that information. Additionally, the whistleblower must not have been involved in any criminal conduct related to the fraud.

Documentation and Evidence Needed

  1. Detailed Reports: Comprehensive written statements that describe the fraudulent activities in detail.
  2. Internal Documents: Emails, memos, contracts, invoices, and other internal documents that provide evidence of the false claims or fraudulent actions.
  3. Financial Records: Evidence such as billing records, financial statements, or accounting documents showing overbilling, false claims, or other discrepancies.
  4. Witness Testimonies: Statements or depositions from other employees or individuals who can corroborate the fraud.
  5. Supporting Data: Any additional data or records that substantiate the claims, such as patient medical records in healthcare fraud cases, or product delivery logs in defense contractor fraud.

These documents and evidence are crucial for building a compelling qui tam case and assisting the DOJ in their investigation. A well-documented case increases the likelihood of government intervention and successful resolution.

Conclusion

Qui tam lawsuits under the Federal False Claims Act are crucial for exposing fraud and recovering government funds. Whistleblowers, known as qui tam relators, play a crucial role in this process by providing direct, non-public information about fraudulent activities. These lawsuits not only help recover taxpayer dollars but also promote integrity and accountability in various sectors.

If you have knowledge of fraud involving government funds, consider stepping forward. Whistleblowers are protected by law and can receive substantial financial rewards. For those considering this path, seeking legal guidance from a Medicare fraud lawyer can provide the necessary support and ensure your case is handled correctly.

Leave a comment